Difference Between Coaching and Mentoring
Just imagine someone asking this question: What is the difference between mentoring and coaching? There is no doubt that this will leave a lot of people at six and seven years old. The reasoning is that many people don’t seem to know the disparity between the two. Indeed, in countless cases, people use the two management techniques interchangeably. While this works in a certain context, there are contrasts between them. In an attempt to provide a satisfactory answer, we have launched a research project on the subject.
As you read on, you can be sure that we will explain the difference between coaching and mentoring with examples to help you grasp the drift. For now, we encourage you to grab a pizza and a ham, as it promises to be an interesting journey.
Difference Between Mentoring and Coaching
What is the difference between coaching and mentoring? Well, in this section, we’ll help you spot the disparity, treating each of the two concepts in the same context.
- Aim: It is important to consider the objective of entering into either of the two learning processes. Fundamentally, the goal of coaching a task-oriented process is to ensure that a learner learns how to accomplish a task within a given time frame. A coach/coachee relationship exists between the two, while the other transfers skills or technical know-how to the other. On the other hand, mentoring is about building a relationship based on mutual trust, which means that it is relationship-focused. However, nine times out of ten, a defined goal serves as the basis for establishing the premises of such relationships.
- Duration: Another factor that plays a key role here is the duration of such a process. More often than not, the task-oriented technique is a short-term process. The shortest part of this process may take place in a few sessions and that will be the end of the whole process. In contrast to the other form, the development-oriented process has a long-term goal, which is the period of time during which the two people involved need to bond. Sometimes this process takes between 9 and 2 months, depending on the goals that the people have set for themselves. The duration is, therefore, one difference between coaching and mentoring.
- Drive: The next factor to consider when trying to differentiate between the two is the motivation behind them. This is because the task-based process is performance-driven, which means that the goal is to make the learner a better worker. Therefore, it is always about helping the learner hone his or her skills and the program will end as soon as the new skills are acquired. Similarly, mentoring is about developing an individual for their current job and for the future.
- Structure: Coaching, depending on the organization, can be done almost instantaneously on a particular topic or theme. When there are many people to be coached, the organization often designs it to take into account one or two elements. These may include the area of expertise, the evaluation criteria and the competencies required. The developmental process is not conducted on the spur of the moment. Each step must be designed to ensure that the objective is maintained.
Definitions of Coaching and Mentoring
Do you wish to know the definition of coaching and mentoring? If so, you’re sweating because this section will take care of it. Coaching is a task-based management technique or learning process that takes place between people. Since the main goal is to solve a problem, all efforts are directed towards achieving that goal or task. The people involved are the coach, who is the teacher, and the protégé or learner.
Most importantly, the process does not last long, which means that it only takes place over a short period of time during which the protégé is supposed to carry out the learning and task-solving processes. But then the learner will be assessed to determine what he or she has learned before he or she is considered to have successfully completed the process.
- On the other hand, mentoring is a long-term process that relies on developing a person by building mutual trust and a relationship with them. It takes a long time to complete, which is why it is a long-term management technique. As the two people involved get along, they learn to understand each other, which helps them build relationships and mutual trust. Fundamentally, the mentoree teaches the other person to trust each other, allowing them to share real-life experiences in the hope that they will get reasonable answers or solutions. The goal of this process is usually to build on it. In order to achieve this, a model for the development of the mentoree is designed.
- At this point, you have finished breaking down the definitions of coaching and mentoring. We will now proceed to other key elements to help you understand them properly.
Coaching vs Mentoring Comparison Table
Now, we will go ahead to help you spot the difference between coaching and mentoring.
|Basis of Comparison||Coaching||Mentoring|
|Purpose||It is undertaken by an organization for the accomplishment of a task||The objective is generally to develop a person through a relationship based on mutual respect and trust.|
|Design||This is merely well-structured||This is usually perfectly structured|
|Drive||This is performance-driven||This is development-driven|
|Duration||Short term||Long term|
|Evaluation||Success is viewed form a broad prism||Goals are defined and success is measured|
Conclusion of the Main Difference Between Coaching vs Mentoring
Are you looking for definition coaching and mentoring online? If so, we have given you everything you need to know about coaching and mentoring definition. Well, it doesn’t stop there; we’ve also managed to differentiate the techniques used in the management field. Overall, individuals and organizations engage in both courses with the goal of improving themselves in what they do.
For example, in a broader concept, a company considers mentoring when it wants to develop new talent, break down organizational barriers, and for other reasons. In terms of task-oriented processes, companies choose it when workers do not meet expectations when specific skills are scarce when there is a need to improve performance, and so on. Although they tend to share some striking similarities, we have to say that there are many disparities between them.
The difference between mentoring and coaching is something that many people find hard to spot. But we’ve been able to help you do that, haven’t we? As the CEO of your company, this article will help you know exactly what you need for your workers.